LBW (leg before wicket) is cricket’s most argued-about dismissal, but the law itself is a simple checklist. Under Law 36 of the MCC Laws of Cricket, a batter is out LBW only when five things are all true: the delivery is legal, the ball did not pitch outside leg stump, it hit the batter’s body before the bat, the impact was in line (with one exception), and the ball would have gone on to hit the stumps. Miss any one of those and the answer is not out.
This guide walks through each check, the tricky cases that confuse even seasoned fans (switch hits, full tosses, the “no shot” clause), and how DRS and umpire’s call fit on top of the law.
Key takeaways
- A ball that pitches outside leg stump can never produce an LBW, however plumb it looks.
- If the batter is hit outside the line of off stump while playing a genuine shot, it is not out. Offer no shot, and that protection disappears.
- Off side and leg side are fixed by the batter’s stance when the bowler starts the run-up, so a late switch hit does not change them.
- On DRS, “umpire’s call” means the technology is too close to overrule the on-field decision. The team keeps its review.
The five conditions of Law 36
Law 36.1 lists the conditions in order. Umpires effectively run through them like a flowchart, and so should you when you shout at the TV.
| Check | What the law requires | Not out if… |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Legal delivery | The ball is not a no-ball | The bowler overstepped or it was otherwise a no-ball |
| 2. Pitching | Ball pitches in line between the wickets or on the off side (or does not pitch at all) | It pitched outside leg stump |
| 3. Body before bat | Ball hits the batter’s person without touching the bat first | It hit bat first, or bat and pad at the same instant |
| 4. Impact | Point of impact is between the wickets, even if above the bails | Impact outside off stump while playing a genuine shot, or outside leg stump at all |
| 5. Hitting the stumps | But for the interception, the ball would have hit the wicket | It was going over, past leg or past off stump |
Two details in that table surprise people. First, the impact can be above the height of the bails and still count; the question is only whether the ball would have hit the stumps, not where on the body it struck. Second, the law asks about the first interception only. If the ball clips the pad and then the bat, the pad contact is what matters.
Why “pitched outside leg” is always not out
This is the oldest protection in the law and the one with the clearest logic. A batter cannot be expected to use the bat to defend a ball that lands outside leg stump and spins or seams back in, because the body is naturally in the way. So the Laws simply rule it out. It does not matter if Hawk-Eye shows the ball smashing into middle stump: pitched outside leg means not out.
Pitching in line or outside off stump are both fine for the bowler. That is why left-arm spinners bowling to right-handers, or off-spinners to left-handers, win so many LBWs: their stock ball pitches outside off and turns back in.
The impact rule and the “no shot” clause
Law 36.1.4 is where most of the arguments start. Normally the ball must strike the batter between the wickets, in other words in line with the stumps. If a batter plays a genuine shot and is struck outside the line of off stump, they survive.
The exception is when the striker makes “no genuine attempt to play the ball with the bat”, in the words of the Law. Then the impact can be in line or outside off stump. This exists to stop batters simply kicking away balls that pitch outside off and nip back. Padding up with the bat tucked behind the pad, a common habit against off-spin in the past, is exactly what this clause punishes.
Note what the exception does not do: it never helps the bowler on the leg side. A ball striking the pad outside leg stump is not out whether or not the batter offered a shot.
What counts as a “genuine attempt”?
This is the umpire’s judgement. A bat thrust well forward alongside the pad usually counts as a shot. A bat raised high in a deliberate leave, or held behind the front pad, usually does not. Coaches teach young batters a simple habit for this reason: if you are going to leave a ball that might be coming back in, leave it with your pad well outside the line, not in front of off stump.
Tricky cases: switch hits, full tosses and bat-pad
Switch hits and reverse sweeps
Law 36.3 says the off side is set by the striker’s batting position when the ball comes into play, and Law 20.5 says the ball comes into play when the bowler starts the run-up (or the bowling action, if there is no run-up). So if a left-hander switches to a right-handed stance after the bowler has started running in, “leg side” for LBW purposes is still the left-hander’s leg side.
A well-known example came at the 2024 Women’s T20 World Cup. On October 13, 2024, Australia’s Phoebe Litchfield was given out LBW against India while attempting a reverse shot off Deepti Sharma. She reviewed, and the decision was overturned because the ball had pitched outside her leg stump, judged from her original left-handed stance, as Wisden explained the next day. Several India players were unhappy, but the umpires had applied the Law correctly.
Full tosses
If the ball hits the batter on the full, there is no pitching point to judge, so check 2 is skipped. Law 36.2.3 tells the umpire to assume the ball would have carried on along its existing path, whether or not it would have pitched later. A full toss can be plumb LBW.
Bat and pad together
When the ball hits bat and pad at the same time, Law 36.2.2 treats it as hitting the bat first, so the batter cannot be LBW. On replays this is why third umpires zoom in on UltraEdge for a spike that lines up with the frame where the ball reaches the pad.
LBW and DRS: how umpire’s call works
The Decision Review System came into international cricket in 2009, and ball-tracking turned LBW from pure judgement into something viewers can measure. But the ICC deliberately left room for the on-field umpire. Here is how a review breaks down:
- No-ball and edge. The third umpire checks the front foot and looks for any bat contact first.
- Pitching. There is no umpire’s call here. If more than half the ball pitches outside leg stump, it is outside leg; otherwise the bowler gets it.
- Impact. The zone runs between the outer edges of off and leg stump. If only part of the ball is inside the zone, the on-field decision stands (“umpire’s call”).
- Wickets. The projected ball must hit the stumps zone. Since an ICC change in 2016, that zone runs to the outer edges of the stumps rather than their centre, and since 2021 it has extended to the top of the bails rather than the bottom. A projection clipping less than half the ball into the zone is umpire’s call.
The practical consequence: the same delivery can be out or not out depending on what the umpire originally gave. A ball shaving the bails stays “out” if the umpire raised the finger and stays “not out” if they did not. When a review comes back umpire’s call, the reviewing team keeps that review.
Remember that the Laws (written by MCC) and the playing conditions (set by the ICC for internationals, and by organisers for leagues and domestic cricket) are separate layers. In club cricket without DRS, there is no umpire’s call. There is just the umpire.
A short history of the LBW law
LBW was not part of the earliest written Laws. A 1774 revision made a batter out if he deliberately stopped the ball from hitting the wicket with his leg, which forced umpires to judge intent. By 1788 intent was dropped, and in 1839 MCC settled on the idea that the ball must pitch between the wickets and be going on to hit them. That wording lasted almost a century.
An experimental change in 1935 allowed LBW from balls pitching outside off stump, provided the batter was struck in line, and it entered the Laws in 1937. The “no shot” provision, which lets batters be out when struck outside off without offering a stroke, spread worldwide from 1972 and was written into the Laws in 1980. Each change was aimed at the same thing: stopping batters from using pads as a second bat.
How to judge LBW like an umpire
If you umpire a club or school match, or just want to win more arguments in the stands, run the checks in this order:
- Before the ball: note whether the batter is right- or left-handed as the bowler starts the run-up. That fixes off and leg.
- As it lands: watch the pitching point. Outside leg means stop thinking; it is not out.
- At impact: was there any bat first? Was the impact in line? If outside off, was a genuine shot offered?
- After impact: picture the path. Consider height (a bouncing ball striking high on the thigh may go over), the angle from wide of the crease, and how far the batter was down the pitch. The further forward, the more doubt, and doubt goes to the batter.
That last point matters. The Laws do not say “benefit of the doubt” in Law 36, but long-standing umpiring practice gives it to the batter on LBW, which is why on-field umpires tend to be cautious when a batter is struck well forward. If you enjoy the finer points of the Laws, our guide to the DLS method for rain-hit matches unpacks another rule that baffles fans.
What do you think? Join the discussion in our CricAmore forums and share your take with fellow fans.
Frequently asked questions
Can a batter be out LBW if the ball hits them outside off stump?
Only if they made no genuine attempt to play the ball with the bat. If they played a real shot and were hit outside the line of off stump, it is not out.
Can you be out LBW off a full toss?
Yes. With no pitching point to judge, the umpire only needs the impact to be in line and the ball’s continued path to be hitting the stumps.
Can a batter be LBW off a no-ball?
No. The first condition of Law 36 is that the delivery is not a no-ball, so an LBW on a no-ball is always overturned. In ODIs and T20Is the next ball is a free hit, on which a batter cannot be LBW either.
What does umpire’s call mean in an LBW review?
It means ball-tracking shows the impact or the hit on the stumps is too marginal to overturn the on-field decision, so the original call stands and the reviewing side keeps its review.
Sources: MCC Laws of Cricket – Law 36, ICC – DRS umpire’s call changes, cricket.com.au – Umpire’s call explained, Wisden, Wikipedia – Leg before wicket



4 Comments